Washington follows a pure comparative fault rule that lets injured drivers, passengers and pedestrians recover compensation even when they carry part of the blame for a crash. Many states cut off compensation entirely once an injured person’s fault crosses a set threshold, usually 50 or 51 percent, but Washington applies no such limit. A driver found 80 percent responsible for a collision can still recover for the remaining 20 percent, and the same principle applies to a pedestrian struck while partly at fault for how they crossed a street. The rule exists because real collisions are rarely one-sided, and that stops a single disputed fact from wiping out an otherwise valid claim.
That same feature changes how insurance adjusters handle a case from the first phone call. Because Washington reduces a payout by the injured person’s fault percentage rather than eliminating it outright, adjusters have learned to contest that percentage rather than deny a claim entirely. A driver who was rear-ended might be told they contributed by braking too hard, and a pedestrian struck in a crosswalk might be told they stepped out a half-second early. Understanding how that percentage gets built, and which pieces of evidence move it, often matters as much to the final settlement as the crash itself.
What pure comparative fault actually means
Washington’s approach stands apart from two other systems used elsewhere in the country. Under contributory negligence, still used in a small number of states, any fault at all on the injured person’s part can bar recovery completely, and under modified comparative fault, used across much of the Midwest and several Western states, recovery disappears once the injured person’s share reaches 50 or 51 percent. Washington uses neither approach, and fault is instead calculated as a percentage for each party involved, with the injured person’s compensation reduced by their own share no matter how high it ends up being. A concrete example makes the distinction clear, since an insurer or jury that determines a claimant suffered $100,000 in damages but carries 40 percent of the fault would reduce the recoverable amount to $60,000 rather than erasing it entirely, and even a claimant found 90 percent at fault keeps a right to the remaining 10 percent, a meaningful protection in a crash with genuinely mixed causes. This design keeps a fault dispute from becoming an all-or-nothing bet, though it also means the specific percentage assigned to each side carries real financial weight, and that is exactly why the number gets contested so often.
How an insurer arrives at a fault percentage
Adjusters build a fault percentage from physical and recorded evidence rather than guesswork, at least in theory. Police reports, vehicle damage patterns, skid marks, traffic signal timing, and any available dashcam or surveillance footage all feed into that calculation, along with witness statements from anyone unconnected to either party. Reviewing how an insurer applied Washington comparative fault rules to a specific crash often turns up assumptions that do not match the physical evidence on file, particularly when the adjuster worked from a short police summary rather than the full report.
Pulling together shared blame injury claims that hold up under scrutiny usually means requesting the complete evidence file and comparing it line by line against the percentage the insurer has offered, since a single overlooked detail can change the number by ten points or more. An adjuster might assign 30 percent fault to a driver based on a rough read of a police summary, without accounting for a mechanical failure in the other vehicle or a signal malfunction that never made it into the initial paperwork.
Why this protects pedestrians as much as drivers
Pedestrian claims raise a version of the same dispute, since a driver who was speeding, distracted, or ran a red light can still argue that the pedestrian contributed by crossing mid-block or stepping off the curb before the signal changed, and Washington’s pure comparative fault rule means that argument reduces a payout rather than eliminating it, which changes the calculation for both sides and takes away much of the incentive to deny a pedestrian claim outright. Insurers still raise these arguments regularly, since a 20 or 30 percent reduction on a serious injury claim represents real money even when it falls short of blocking the claim entirely. A pedestrian accident injury lawyer typically pulls the same category of evidence used in vehicle collisions, including signal timing data, nearby business or traffic camera footage, and accounts from anyone who saw the crash happen, and crosswalk positioning, walk-signal timing, and the driver’s speed at impact all factor into how a percentage gets assigned, since small details in that evidence can change the outcome considerably. A pedestrian struck while walking against a signal may still recover most of their damages if the driver was traveling well above the posted limit, because Washington divides fault based on the full picture rather than a single factor.
Protecting a shared-blame claim after a crash
Adrenaline can mask pain for hours after a collision, which is why an evaluation on the day of the crash, or the day after at the latest, does more than treat an injury. That early visit also creates documentation that carries more weight than a report written weeks later, and it establishes a timeline that is harder for an adjuster to dispute. Photos of vehicle positions, road conditions, and any visible injuries add to that same record while the details are still fresh in memory.
Claimants often weaken their own position without meaning to, usually by giving a recorded statement to an adjuster before understanding how the fault percentage will be calculated. A statement given soon after a crash, while still shaken or unsure of exact details, can include phrasing an insurer later cites to argue partial fault. Waiting to give a formal statement until the physical evidence has been reviewed tends to produce a more accurate account and lowers the risk of an inflated percentage sticking to the final number.
Under pure comparative fault, a share of blame reduces a recovery but never eliminates it. Karns & Karns Personal Injury and Accident Attorneys can contest an inflated fault percentage and protect the value of what remains. Call 1-800-4-THE-WIN (1-800-484-3946) to discuss your claim.


